Episode 25: Annuity Bonus Rates Alone Don’t Matter

Reading Time: 4 minutes

In my work with clients approaching retirement, I’ve noticed a troubling trend that can significantly impact their financial decisions: the allure of annuity bonus rates presented at dinner seminars. These events often promote annuities with attractive bonuses, claiming outsized benefits that can be hard to resist. I find it necessary to emphasize that while these bonuses might sound compelling, they often don’t hold up under scrutiny.

The reality is that many people, understandably, get fixated on these numbers. They come to me excited about a product that offers a 25%, 45%, or even a “million percent” (sarcasm) bonus. This fixation is not their fault; the presentations are designed to make these bonuses the focal point, overshadowing the actual financial implications and the true long-term benefits.

You MUST step back from the hype. The number that truly matters is the guaranteed contractual income—the real amount you’ll receive over time. Everything else, if not grounded in a contractual guarantee, is mere speculation and can lead to decisions that aren’t in your best financial interest.

Understanding the True Value of Bonuses in Annuities

It’s important to clarify the role and value of bonuses. Often highlighted in promotional materials, bonuses can seem like a key feature, but their true impact on annuity returns can be misleading.

Here’s the straightforward truth: if we’re focusing solely on income, the bonus, while not entirely negligible, should be one of the last factors to consider. This is because the real measure of an annuity’s worth lies in how much guaranteed income it can provide you for each dollar invested. Yes, a bonus can appear to increase your initial investment, but it is only one part of a more complex calculation.

The primary criteria to consider when choosing an annuity based on guaranteed income should include not just the annuity bonus rates, but also the roll-up rate and the payout rate. Together, these factors determine the annuity’s overall effectiveness. While a bonus can contribute to increasing your account value initially, it’s the combination of a favorable roll-up rate and an advantageous payout rate that truly maximizes your income.

In essence, think of the bonus as the icing on the cake—not the cake itself. It’s a supplement to the fundamental elements that secure and grow your retirement income effectively. Understanding this distinction is critical in making informed decisions that align with your long-term financial goals.

The Three Essential Calculations for Maximizing Annuity Income

To truly maximize your guaranteed income from an annuity, you need to focus on three essential calculations. Understanding these will help ensure that every dollar you invest works as hard as possible for your retirement.

  1. The Annuity Bonus Rate: Initially, I mentioned setting aside the allure of bonuses, and here’s why. While a bonus can seem attractive, it’s just one piece of the puzzle. It adds a percentage to your initial investment, which can be appealing, but it’s not the cornerstone of a solid income strategy. However, it is a factor, and as such, we consider it, but with the proper perspective.
  2. The Roll-Up Rate: This is where things start to get interesting. The roll-up rate is the guaranteed percentage by which your income value will increase every year you defer taking money out. This rate can be applied as simple interest or compound interest, and it plays a critical role in building the future value of your annuity. Deciding when to start taking income can significantly impact the roll-up, and thus, your eventual returns.
  3. The Payout Rate: This is the percentage of your accumulated income value that the annuity will pay out annually once you activate the income. The payout rate is crucial because it directly determines the actual dollar amount you will receive each year. This rate often increases with age; the older you are when you activate the income, the higher the payout rate will be.

Case Study: Comparing Annuities with Different Bonuses and Rates

To illustrate the impact of the three critical factors— annuity bonus rates, roll-up rates, and payout rates—let’s delve into a real-world comparison between two annuities. This example will demonstrate how seemingly minor differences in terms can lead to significant variations in the guaranteed income you can expect.

Annuity Example #1 features an 8% bonus, an 8% compounding interest roll-up rate, and a 6.5% payout rate at the time of income activation. The compounded roll-up is particularly beneficial over time, as it allows the income value to grow exponentially.

Annuity Example #2, on the other hand, offers a more eye-catching 20% bonus, which is more than double that of Example #1. It also provides a 10% simple interest roll-up rate and a slightly lower payout rate of 6.2% at the time of income activation. At first glance, this annuity might seem the more lucrative option due to its higher bonus and roll-up rate.

Now, let’s analyze the outcomes:

  • Annuity #1, with its compounded roll-up rate, ultimately provides a guaranteed income of $64,968 annually upon activation—almost $65,000.
  • Annuity #2, despite its higher bonus and roll-up rate, offers a lower guaranteed income of $54,500 annually. This represents a 19% difference in income compared to Annuity #1.

This case study starkly illustrates how critical it is to look beyond initial figures like bonuses. While Annuity #2 might initially appear more attractive due to its higher bonus, the combination of a lower payout rate and the nature of its roll-up calculation (simple interest vs. compounding) results in a lower guaranteed income. This example underscores the importance of understanding how these factors interplay to affect the overall benefit of the annuity.

Through this comparison, it becomes clear that the highest contractual guarantees often come from a balanced approach to all three factors, rather than focusing on one (like the bonus) to the exclusion of others.

In this week’s podcast episode, I show you how I effectively assess annuity options WITHOUT using hyped up annuity bonus rates as numbers, and how you’ll always know when you’re getting an unbiased analysis of what each annuity can actually offer you.

Make sure you watch it, and if you’re currently looking at an annuity product that’s been presented with a bonus that you feel like you just can’t pass up, schedule a quick call on my calendar and we’ll look at it together to make 100% sure it will meet your income needs.

Podcast Episode 25: Annuity Bonus Rates Alone Don’t Matter

Download Episode 25: Annuity Bonus Rates Alone Don’t Matter on Apple Music


Recent Annuity Newsletters

{"email":"Email address invalid","url":"Website address invalid","required":"Required field missing"}